
- Quickly determine whether you may qualify for compensation with our free case evaluation.
- Our simple, streamlined process connects you with experienced attorneys in just a few steps.
- No upfront costs. You don't pay attorney fees unless your case is successful.
Sign up for your free case review today.
Schedule Your Free ConsultationA Car Lemon Law Attorney in Fort Lauderdale, FL, Can Help You Fight Back Against Defective Vehicle Manufacturers
When a new vehicle has a recurring defect that no one can fix, the frustration goes far beyond inconvenience. You're losing time, losing money, and depending on a car you can't trust. If you're a Florida vehicle owner who has been back to the dealership again and again for the same problem, it’s time to explore your legal options. A Florida Lemon Law lawyer can help you pursue the replacement, refund, or compensation you deserve.
At Feingold, Posner & Draizin Accident Lawyers, we bring over 50 years of combined experience to Lemon Law matters. We've taken on large corporate defendants and their legal teams, and we apply that same strategic mindset to defective vehicle claims against manufacturers and dealers who refuse to make things right.
The longer this situation goes on, the greater the risks. A defective vehicle isn't just a financial headache. A car that stalls unexpectedly on I-95, loses braking response on US-1, or overheats on the Florida Turnpike puts you, your passengers, and everyone around you in danger. Florida law gives consumers meaningful tools to fight back, and an experienced car Lemon Law attorney in Fort Lauderdale, FL, can guide you through every step of the process.
Get started with a free, no-obligation consultation. Call Feingold, Posner & Draizin Accident Lawyers at 954-953-5861 or fill out our online contact form today.
Understanding What Florida's Lemon Law Covers
Florida's Lemon Law statute is formally titled the Motor Vehicle Warranty Enforcement Act. This law is found in Chapter 681 of the Florida Statutes.
Under this law, the manufacturer must buy back or replace a vehicle when the manufacturer, or its authorized service agent, cannot fix a substantial defect within a reasonable number of attempts. The law provides remedies for consumers who purchase or lease new or demonstrator motor vehicles with a “nonconformity.” A "nonconformity" under this law is a defect or condition that substantially impairs the use, value, or safety of the vehicle. In plain terms, this means a problem serious enough to affect how the car runs, what it's worth, or whether it's safe to drive. Defects caused by consumer abuse or unauthorized modifications are generally excluded.
Vehicles that may qualify include:
- New cars, trucks, and vans purchased or leased in Florida
- Demonstrator vehicles sold with a manufacturer's new-vehicle warranty
- Certain leased vehicles covered by the manufacturer's warranty
Common defect categories that may support a claim include:
- Engine failures
- Transmission problems
- Brake malfunctions
- Electrical system failures
- Steering defects
Coverage depends on the specific facts of your purchase and the nature of the defect. A Florida Lemon Law lawyer can assess your situation and your potential eligibility for recourse through the Lemon Law or other avenues.
Beyond the Florida statute, the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act may provide an additional path for relief. This gives consumers options beyond what state law alone offers. An attorney can help you evaluate which avenue, or combination of avenues, makes the most sense for your situation.
The Repair Attempt Requirement in Florida’s Lemon Law and What Counts as “Reasonable”
The repair attempt threshold is where most Lemon Law claims are won or lost. It's frequently misunderstood.
Florida law generally presumes a vehicle is a lemon after three repair attempts for the same nonconformity. This is followed by a final attempt by the manufacturer after you provide proper written notice by registered or express mail.
A vehicle may also qualify if it has been out of service for repairs for a cumulative total of 30 or more days (60 days for a recreational vehicle) within the 24-month Lemon Law rights period. Once the vehicle has been out of service for 15 days, the consumer must notify the manufacturer in writing by registered or express mail and give the manufacturer or its authorized service agent an opportunity to inspect or repair the vehicle.
Meeting the threshold creates a legal presumption, not merely a right to file, shifting the burden to the manufacturer to rebut. Even so, this presumption is not a guarantee. Having an experienced Florida Lemon Law lawyer on your side can help you meet every procedural requirement during this process and address obstacles that can arise.
Documenting Repair Attempt History in Your Florida Lemon Law Claim
Documentation is everything in a Florida Lemon Law case. Every dealership visit should produce a written repair order. You should keep every copy.
Manufacturers and dealers sometimes argue that different visits addressed separate problems, even when the underlying defect is the same. This argument seeks to reset the repair-attempt count. Strong documentation makes that argument much harder to sustain.
Records you should preserve include:
- All repair orders and work orders from every dealership visit
- Loaner vehicle records and towing receipts
- Written communications with the dealer or manufacturer
- Any written defect notification you sent to the manufacturer
- Photos or videos of the defect when it occurs
A Florida Lemon Law lawyer at Feingold, Posner & Draizin can review your repair history. Our firm will assess whether your situation meets the legal threshold. If you have grounds for a Lemon Law claim, we will also help you present that documentation in the most effective way possible.
Remedies Your Florida Lemon Law Lawyer Can Pursue: Replacement, Refund, and Cash Compensation
In cases heard by the Florida New Motor Vehicle Arbitration Board, if a consumer's vehicle is found to be a lemon, the manufacturer must either replace the vehicle or refund the full purchase price. A third option, a negotiated cash settlement, is also possible in some situations.
Here's a plain-language breakdown of the three general categories of relief:
- Replacement vehicle: A comparable new vehicle of similar value allows you to move on without the financial loss of simply walking away from a defective car.
- Full refund: A refund under Florida’s Lemon Law generally includes the purchase price, finance charges, registration fees, and certain incidental costs. The law subtracts a "reasonable offset for use." This offset is calculated using the vehicle's mileage through the date of the settlement agreement or arbitration hearing, whichever occurs first, under the formula established by Florida law.
- Cash settlement: A negotiated monetary payment from the manufacturer may be offered as an alternative to replacement or a full repurchase.
Manufacturers often push cash settlements early in the process. They can be offered quickly and for less than the full value of a replacement or refund. Accepting one without understanding what you're entitled to can leave significant money on the table, which is another reason it’s worth discussing your situation with legal counsel before agreeing to a settlement offer.
A Lawyer’s Representation Without the Burden of Attorney’s Fees
Both Florida's Chapter 681 (§ 681.112) and the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act may provide for attorney's fee recovery in qualifying cases. This means pursuing a claim may not require out-of-pocket legal fees.
The right remedy depends on the facts of your situation. An attorney can help you evaluate which path is most favorable before you accept anything.
The Strategies Manufacturers and Dealers Use to Fight Lemon Law Claims
Manufacturers and their legal teams use many of the same delay, deny, and minimize tactics in Lemon Law claims that insurance companies use in personal injury disputes. The playbook is predictable once you've seen it from the inside. Here are the arguments our attorneys encounter most often:
- Disputing whether the defect is substantial: They argue that the problem doesn't rise to the level of impairing the vehicle's use, value, or safety, even when the driver has experienced repeated failures.
- Claiming consumer misuse or modification: They shift blame to the driver to void warranty coverage and avoid any obligation to repair or replace the vehicle.
- Counting repair attempts differently: They argue that separate dealership visits addressed distinct issues rather than the same recurring defect. This can artificially reset the repair-attempt count.
- Offering a lowball cash settlement early: They present a quick offer before the consumer has had a chance to understand the full value of a replacement or refund.
- Delaying the arbitration or litigation process: They use procedural steps and slow responses to wear the consumer down and pressure them into accepting less.
Our attorneys have spent portions of their careers on the defense side of large corporate and insurance disputes. Our team at Feingold, Posner & Draizin knows how these strategies are built and can anticipate these arguments before they're made.
We structure cases to address weaknesses head-on. We pursue the fullest recovery available rather than reacting after the manufacturer has already set the terms.
The Florida Lemon Law Arbitration Process
Before filing a civil action in court under the Lemon Law, consumers must attempt to seek relief through arbitration under Chapter 681, Florida Statutes. That requirement does not mean giving up the right to go to court. It means working through a defined process first.
Florida's process requires the consumer to complete the manufacturer's certified informal dispute settlement program, if the manufacturer has a certified program. This must be done before invoking the state's New Motor Vehicle Arbitration Board. If the manufacturer doesn't have a certified program, or if you're not satisfied with the outcome of that program, the vehicle owner or lessee can apply directly to the Florida Attorney General's Office. The dispute will then be arbitrated by the Florida New Motor Vehicle Arbitration Board.
A critical protection exists under Florida’s Lemon Law. If a consumer is not satisfied with the decision or the manufacturer's compliance, the consumer may apply to have the dispute submitted to the board for arbitration. Either party may appeal the state arbitration board's decision to circuit court within 30 days of receiving it. If you are dissatisfied with the outcome, an attorney can help you evaluate your options for challenging the decision. If the outcome is unsatisfactory, you may appeal the board's decision to circuit court within the applicable 30-day deadline.
Here's what generally happens at a state board arbitration hearing:
- Submission of repair records and supporting documentation by both parties
- The manufacturer's response and presentation of its defense
- The consumer's presentation of evidence and testimony
- The hearing, conducted in two parts
- The arbitration board's written decision
The first part of the hearing is to determine whether the vehicle is a lemon. If so, the second part of the hearing focuses on determining whether the consumer receives a refund or a replacement vehicle and calculating the amounts to be paid by the manufacturer.
Manufacturers arrive at these hearings with experienced legal representation. Going in without an attorney puts you at a disadvantage. It means you’re on your own when presenting evidence, making legal arguments, and evaluating any offer on the table.
Having a car Lemon Law attorney in Fort Lauderdale, FL, who understands how these proceedings work and how manufacturers prepare for them can make a meaningful difference in the outcome.
Why Choose Feingold, Posner & Draizin as Your Car Lemon Law Attorney in Fort Lauderdale, FL
At Feingold, Posner & Draizin, our attorneys’ prior work experience directly supports the representation we provide for Lemon Law matters.
Eric Feingold served as in-house counsel for a national health insurance company. Craig Posner previously worked as an insurance defense attorney for a large national auto insurance company. Aaron Draizin served as a Shareholder at a prominent statewide insurance defense firm. Together, our attorneys understand how large corporate defendants and their legal teams evaluate claims, exploit weaknesses, and build defenses designed to minimize what they pay out.
That insider knowledge equips us to build your claim from a position of strength. Instead of reacting to the manufacturer's tactics after the fact, our team anticipates them before they're deployed. We structure your case to address those arguments from the start.
Every client at Feingold, Posner & Draizin works directly with an attorney throughout the entire process. You won't be handed off to a paralegal or a case manager. You'll have direct access to the attorney handling your claim, with your representation shaped around your specific situation and goals.
Our firm handles Lemon Law cases on a contingency basis. This means you pay no attorney fees unless the firm achieves a financial recovery on your behalf. And because attorney's fees may be recoverable from the manufacturer in qualifying Lemon Law cases under both Florida's Chapter 681 (§ 681.112) and the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, pursuing a claim may carry no out-of-pocket attorney fees at all.
We treat every client as an individual, not a file number, and provide regular updates on where things stand. Our firm brings the same thorough preparation to a manufacturer defect claim in Florida as we do to any other case we handle.
Contact Feingold, Posner & Draizin Today for a Free, No-Obligation Consultation With a Florida Lemon Law Lawyer
Lemon Law claims have time windows that can close quickly. If your vehicle has been back to the dealership repeatedly for the same problem and the manufacturer still hasn't fixed it, waiting to act may cost you the right to pursue a claim at all.
You don't have to navigate this process alone, and you don't have to accept the first offer a manufacturer puts in front of you.
Feingold, Posner & Draizin Accident Lawyers offers free consultations with no obligation. Let our team put insider knowledge to work for you. Call 954-953-5861 today or fill out our online contact form to schedule your free consultation with a car Lemon Law attorney in Fort Lauderdale, FL. If you’re ready to Ace Your Case, it starts with having the right team in your corner.
